What makes a story boring enough to listen to at bedtime

Five checks that tell you whether a story asks anything of the listener, with a two-minute test you can run on any story.

Abe BurnettBuilds Ho-Hum

Boring Stories5 min read

Published
In this guide
  1. Why "avoid cliffhangers" is not enough
  2. Check one: stakes
  3. Check two: names and facts to track
  4. Check three: open questions
  5. Check four: feeling
  6. Check five: surprise
  7. Run it on a story in two minutes
  8. Questions people ask
  9. A story from your own day

A story is boring enough for bedtime when it asks nothing of you: no stakes, no new names to track, no open question, no strong feeling and no surprise. Fail any one of those five checks and the story asks you for something. You can count them in two minutes.

Why "avoid cliffhangers" is not enough

You may have heard that a bedtime story should avoid cliffhangers or be low-stakes. Both are true. Neither is a test.

A story with no cliffhanger can still ask you to remember six names, laugh at a joke or wonder who did it. Each of those is a request, and a boring-enough story makes none.

Dullness can be a craft. The show notes for Sleep With Me's episode 310 list the question "How do you go about writing something so dull?" among the episode's questions. We do not say what the episode answers; read it for that.

The five checks below are our own test. They are not research findings, and nobody has tested them. They tell you how much a story asks of a listener. They do not tell you what listening does to anyone.

Check one: stakes

Ask whether anything matters if it goes wrong. A missed train is a crisis in a thriller. A missed train in a story about timetables costs nobody anything.

CNN's 12 May 2025 article on falling asleep to shows and podcasts covers listening to a show you have heard before and know the ending of. We read that as a point about stakes: a known ending removes the question "will it work out?". That reading is ours, not the article's conclusion, and the article is about shows, not about these checks.

Tick this check if anything could go badly wrong for anyone in the story.

Check two: names and facts to track

Count the new names in the first two minutes. People, places, companies, dates: each one is a small file you are asked to open and keep open.

Our rule: one new name or none is boring enough. Three or four makes the opening busy, even if every one of them is harmless. A story that begins "On the second floor there is a cupboard" has asked you to track nothing.

Tick this check if more than one new name or fact appears in the first two minutes.

Check three: open questions

Ask whether anything is left unresolved, and whether the story promises an answer. "Why did she leave the house?" is an open question. So is a hint that something will be explained later.

Dull stories can fall into this trap too. "We will come back to that" is a promise, and it asks the listener to wait for the return. A boring-enough story either closes each thing as it opens it or never opens anything.

Tick this check if you would want to know how it ends.

Check four: feeling

Ask whether the story wants you to laugh, fear or care. Comedy asks you to react. Horror asks you to react harder. A story that wants you to love its characters asks for care, which is a request too.

The target is flat: plain description, even tone, nobody's feelings at risk. If you want a story that moves you, these checks point the wrong way, and that is a fine thing to want at another time of day.

Tick this check if the story is trying to make you feel something.

Check five: surprise

Ask whether anything unexpected happens: a twist, a strange fact, a sudden change of scene. Surprise is the story asking you to update what you thought was coming.

Familiarity is the quiet advantage here. A story whose shape you can predict, or one you already know, passes this check by default and often passes checks one and three too. It can still fail on names or feeling, so score it anyway.

Tick this check if the story could surprise you.

Run it on a story in two minutes

Play or read the first two minutes of the story, then score it on this sheet. Copy it as is.

  • Stakes: tick if anything could go badly wrong for anyone.
  • Names: tick if more than one new name or fact appears.
  • Open question: tick if anything is left unresolved or promised.
  • Feeling: tick if the story tries to make you laugh, fear or care.
  • Surprise: tick if anything could catch you off guard.

Our rule of thumb, not research: zero ticks is boring enough. One tick means the story asks one thing of you; swap it if that is the thing you cannot give tonight. Two or more ticks means put it back.

Here are two passages, written for this post and labelled illustrative. Neither comes from any Ho-Hum story.

Marta had until Friday to find out who had moved the filing cabinet. She suspected Dennis, the new manager, who had already lied about the budget twice. At ten to five, the lights went out.

That one ticks all five: a deadline, two names, a mystery, suspicion and a surprise at the end.

The supply cupboard on the second floor holds paper, staples and tape. The paper comes in packs of five hundred sheets. The staples are in a box beside the tape. Nothing in the cupboard has changed since last month.

That one ticks none. It has no one to worry about, nothing to remember, nothing to wonder about, nothing to feel and nothing to be surprised by.

The sheet has limits. It scores what a story asks of you, not how well it is told, and a passage can score zero and still be unpleasant to listen to. No study here tested these checks, so use the sheet as a way to count, not as a promise.

Questions people ask

Are the five checks based on research?

No. They are our own test, built from the idea that a dull story asks nothing of the listener. Nobody has studied them, so treat them as a practical way to count what a story asks of you.

Does a story that passes all five checks help me fall asleep?

The checks measure how much a story asks of you, not what listening does to you. We make no claim that passing them changes how anyone sleeps. They only tell you whether a story is dull in the five ways we count.

Can a story I already know pass the checks?

Often, yes. A story you know well has no surprise left, and it often has no open question or real stakes left either. It can still fail on names or feeling, so run the two-minute test on it like any other.

How many new names are too many in the first two minutes?

Our rule is that more than one is too many. Each new name, place or date is something to remember. Zero or one new name is boring enough; three or four makes the opening busy.

A story from your own day

Ho-Hum is an app for adults, coming to iPhone, that writes a boring bedtime story that begins with the dull parts of your day, and reads it aloud. Your day goes to an AI writer and a voice service, to be written and read aloud, and the voice is an AI voice. Run the scoring sheet on any story first, whether it comes from an app, a podcast or your own pen.

Abe Burnett builds Ho-Hum. He writes here for adults whose day is still running at bedtime.