AI bedtime stories for adults, and what "AI" can mean

An AI story can mean an AI writer, an AI voice or both, so here are the questions that tell you which one an app means.

Abe BurnettBuilds Ho-Hum

Boring Stories5 min read

Published
In this guide
  1. Three choices hide inside one word
  2. Where Ho-Hum lands on each
  3. What an AI writer is good and bad at
  4. The voice is AI too, library or not
  5. Where your words go
  6. Who should skip an AI story app
  7. Questions people ask
  8. Ho-Hum's answers, in plain words

"AI bedtime story" can mean an AI writer, an AI voice or both, and an app that does not say which has not answered you. Ask three questions: who writes the story, who voices it, and is it made fresh tonight or played from a library. Then ask a fourth: what happens to what you type.

Three choices hide inside one word

"AI" is three choices that happen to share a label, and an app can pick a different answer for each. We think an app should state all three in a sentence a tired adult can read once at 11 PM.

Vendors explain the choices, but each explains them to sell its own model. ELYND's article on AI sleep stories for adults separates stories generated each night from a fixed library. Noctuary describes its app as one that writes a new story on a topic you pick and reads it aloud in AI voices. Both are the vendors' own descriptions of their own apps. The table below applies to any app, ours included.

Choice What to ask What a clear answer looks like
Writer Who or what writes the story I hear tonight? "An AI writer writes it from what you give it," or "people wrote the library."
Voice Who or what reads it aloud? "An AI voice," or a statement that a person read it.
Library Is tonight's story made fresh, or played from stored audio? "Fresh each night," "stored," or a stated mix, with each part labelled.

Where Ho-Hum lands on each

Ho-Hum is coming to iPhone and is for adults. Its opening is written fresh from your lines each night by an AI writer, and the rest of the story comes from our recorded library, read in the same AI voice. "Recorded" here means stored audio made with that voice, not a person reading. So the story is a hybrid: a fresh start, then stored material in one voice.

What an AI writer is good and bad at

An AI writer is good at producing a story on demand, from any starting point, at any hour. It is bad at being reliable. Ho-Hum's terms say it directly: stories are generated and can be wrong or odd. We put that sentence in the post because an app that hides it is asking you to trust a machine without telling you the machine is guessing.

Here is our opinion, labelled as such. A story meant to be dull needs constraints. Left alone, a writer drifts toward drama, because drama is what most stories contain. Telling a writer to keep things uneventful works only when the rules are firm. If an app says its stories are "calm" but never says what it tells the writer to avoid, ask. Ho-Hum does not claim any result from a story; a story is a story.

An example, made up for illustration. You type "the standup ran long and the inbox is full." An AI writer could turn that into a quiet scene about a long meeting, or into a thriller about a rogue email. Which one you get depends on how the app instructs the writer, not on the word "AI."

The voice is AI too, library or not

Ho-Hum's voice is an AI voice. We say it plainly because a stored library can mislead here: "recorded" sounds like a person sitting at a microphone, and in Ho-Hum's case it is not. A library read in an AI voice is still a library, and a fresh story read in the same AI voice is still fresh. The two choices are independent.

That independence is the point of the table. An app can write fresh and play stored audio, write a library and voice it live, or do both with different voices. If an app's page says "stories read aloud" without saying by whom, treat that as a question, not an answer. We would rather you ask than guess.

Where your words go

This is the fourth question. An app that writes your story on a server has to send your words there. A fair page says who receives them, what the recipient does with them, and how long the app keeps them.

Ho-Hum's answer comes from its own consent sheet, terms and privacy page, and we state only what they state. Your day goes to an AI writer and a voice service, to be written and read aloud. The notes you type stay yours: you let us use them to write your story, and we delete them from our servers once your phone has the whole story. That sentence answers one question, how long we keep what you type. We never put a story written from your notes into the shared library or show it to anyone else.

For anything else about who receives your words, read the privacy page. Do the same with any app: if its page answers one of the three questions and ignores the others, you have found the gap.

Who should skip an AI story app

Skip it if you want a person's voice. An AI voice is not a person, and no amount of polish changes that. Skip it if you want no AI in your bedtime at all, which is a reasonable preference. Skip it if you want guided meditation, music or a clinical program, because a story is none of those.

If you are comfortable with an AI writer and an AI voice, and you want a dull story that starts from your own day, an app that answers the four questions plainly is a good choice. Ho-Hum is one choice among several, not the only one. Ask the same questions of every app you try, including ours.

Questions people ask

What does AI mean in an AI bedtime story app?

It can mean an AI writer that composes the story, an AI voice that reads it aloud, or both. A third question sits beside those two: whether the story is made fresh each night or played from a stored library.

Can an AI bedtime story be wrong or odd?

Yes. Ho-Hum's terms say stories are generated and can be wrong or odd. If an app never says so, ask how it handles a story that comes out strange, and whether you can skip it.

Is a stored story library written by a person?

Not necessarily. A library is stored audio, and it can be written and voiced by AI the same way a fresh story is. Ask the app who writes the library and who voices it.

What should an AI story app say about what I type?

It should say who receives your words, what each recipient does with them, and how long the app keeps them. If a page answers only one of those, you are missing two answers.

Ho-Hum's answers, in plain words

Ho-Hum is an iPhone app for adults, and it is coming to iPhone. You write a line or two about the dull parts of your day; an AI writer writes a deliberately boring story from those lines, and an AI voice reads it aloud.

Abe Burnett builds Ho-Hum. He writes here for adults whose day is still running at bedtime.